"Sage"
--I killed the protagonist--
=He needed to die=
--I killed the antagonist too--
=He deserved to die=
--But I couldn't kill the mentor--
--The wise man and the sage--
=He didn't have any wrongs against him=
(But I guess, in the end)
*...He didn't have any rights, either...*
Explication.
First person point of view: It shows that it was the author, and not the characters in the story that did all of this, it was the author who orchestrated all the deaths.
Word choice: kill, its a brutal word, the word of a murderer, not something accidental, it had a purpose.
Word choice: needed (the protagonist). Many authors can't kill their hero's, they feel their readers would like to see the hero live happily ever after, but sometimes the hero needs to die, and when they do, it's always a spectacular death, it is always worthy, because somethings are worth dying for.
Word choice: deserved (antagonist. The antagonist is usually the bad guy in the story, not always bad, but he's the opposition, and everyone knows that opposition is bad (that was sarcasm). But whether opposition is a positive or negative, constructive or destructive idea is neither here nor there. It is either killed,or kills that which it is opposing, and in fairy tales, that is the definition of evil. So, he was killed, and deserved to die just for being who he was, being exactly as his nature dictated.
Concerning the mentor, sage, and wiseman: There is one of these in every story, we know him as Gandalf, Obi-wan, Merlin, Dumbledore, and so many more. In most stories, he dies so the hero can continue on, by himself, and face his final battle the way he needs to: alone. Gandalf dies, true he comes back, and Obi-wan dies, and again, true, he still comes back, Merlin gets locked in a cave (that one always made me laugh), and Dumbledore dies. (Lets not get into the particulars of that one...JK left that too messy...) But, does the sage really die for a fair cause, like the hero, and/or does he die because of who he is, like the villan? No. What is his sin? He has none. So he can't die like the antagonist. So, what is his cause? He has none. So he can't die like the protagonist. Some may argue that his cause is helping the hero. But is that really a cause? No, he is just doing as he see's fit. he's not really helping either side. So, I don't think he should die. He shouldnt have either the heros or the villans death. he doesnt deserve to die. Death is something that should be earned. And both the hero and the villan earned it.
Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment